By Michelle Colleran Cook
Below, is testimony provided by MNA Member Michelle Colleran Cook
on behalf of the MNA Congress on Nursing Practice at a hearing before
the Joint Committee on Health Care, which concerned the issue of
prevention of medication errors in health care settings.
My name is Michelle Colleran Cook. I am employed per diem in the
Recovery Room of a Boston teaching hospital. I am also an instructor
in a LPN School of Nursing and will graduate from Regis College
with a Masters Degree in Nursing Administration in May 1999.
Recently, there have been national and local incidences of nurse
errors in medication administration that have resulted in negative
patient outcomes. Nurses, because they administer the drugs directly
to patients, are the last links in the safe medication administration
chain. Complicating matters is the increased acuity of the patients
they serve, and the decrease in the resources available to nurses
to ensure safe practice. Because of the climate of health care today,
nurses need to become cognizant of their practice’s vulnerability
and vigilant about protecting their practice.
All nurses have been taught the five rights of medication administration.
They were drilled into our conscious in nursing school until they
became part of our unconscious behavior as practicing nurses. The
right patient, the right drug, the right dose, the right route and
the right time form the foundation from which nurses practice safely
when administrating medications to our patients in all health care
settings.
Just as nurses know the five rights of medication administration,
they should also know what rights they have when administering medications.
These "Six Rights for Nurses Administering Medications"
will hopefully guide nurses as they continue to care for patients
despite these turbulent times.
- THE RIGHT TO A COMPLETE AND CLEARLY WRITTEN
ORDER
You, as the nurse, have the right to demand that
an order be complete and clearly written. You have the right to
require that the drug, dose, route and frequency be written by
the physician. All of these components must be present for a physician
order to be considered complete.
It is no longer good practice to accept orders
when the dosage is written as "1 tablet." A complete
order includes specific numerical dosages. For example, Acetaminophen
2 tablets po prn should now be written as Acetaminophen 650 mg.
po prn. It is also no longer safe practice to administer vague
orders such as "Laxative of choice." Drugs ordered need
to be specific and the dose explicit.
Verbal orders should never be taken and telephone
orders should only be taken if the physician is not physically
present. Nurses cognitively know this but often in the interest
of saving time may be tempted not to practice it. Nurses who write
orders for physicians are placing their license and their patients
at risk.
Orders should be legibly written. The Massachusetts
Hospital Coalition recommends physicians use computers to directly
order medications. However, such costly systems may take years
to implement. Until that occurs, nurses need to remember that
it is their duty and right to question physician orders that are
illegible. Cefoxitan and Cefotetan may look alike when hand written
but confusing one drug for the other results in the patient receiving
the wrong medication.
- THE RIGHT TO HAVE THE CORRECT DRUG ROUTE
AND DOSE DISPENSED
Nurses administer medications but it is the pharmacy’s
duty to dispense medications correctly. Pharmacies process and
distribute an incredible volume of medications daily. Pharmacists,
like nurses, are susceptible to the pressures of time and patient
needs and can dispense the incorrect drug or dose. The nurse who
discovers the error then notifies the pharmacy of this oversight.
If all goes well, pharmacy will deliver the medication promptly
to the nursing unit. In this case the system works well.
Sometimes, the nurse is told there is no one from
pharmacy available to deliver the medication. The nurse is given
the option of either waiting for her patient’s medication,
coming to the pharmacy herself to get the medication, or finding
someone else to do so. Such errors of dispensing eat away at nursing
time and energy. They pull nurses away from caring for their patients.
They place patients in jeopardy of not receiving the drug on time.
Additionally, unnecessary stress is placed on the nurse who is
struggling just trying to gather the drugs necessary to care for
her patient. This hurried atmosphere places the nurse in a position
that she may make a medication error in her haste.
Another recommendation from the Massachusetts
Hospital Coalition states that a unit dose system of medication
can decrease the number of medication errors. Many hospitals have
adopted this system of medication administration. However, scenarios
such as the one above coupled with the available technology of
automated medication administration systems such as the Pixis
has placed nurses in a potentially unsafe situation. First developed
to dispense narcotics, these automated systems can be programmed
to allow nurses access to many other types of medications. Now,
in an attempt to address missing or incorrectly dispensed medications,
and decrease the turnaround time of getting the correct drug to
the patient, they are being used widely in acute care hospitals
as quasi satellite pharmacies.
At first, they may be seen by the nurse as a welcome
relief from the frustration of not having medications readily
available to administer. But they must be used with caution. The
nurse enters patient data into the automated medication dispenser;
the machine opens the correct drawer and directs the nurse to
the correct drug compartment where the medication can be found.
But in some systems, when the Pixis drawer opens, the nurse has
access to many drugs. In this situation, the unit dose safeguard
is eliminated and therefore increases the chances of the nurse
selecting the incorrect drug or dose and administering it to their
patient.
- THE RIGHT TO HAVE ACCESS TO INFORMATION
Nurses have the right to expect updated and easily
accessible drug information. This means that the hospital formulary,
a Physicians Desk Reference and a current nursing drug reference
book need to be available to nurses who administer medications.
Nurses have the right to ask questions about the
drugs that they are to administer to their patients. Pharmacists
are the drug experts and nurses should have access to a pharmacist
no matter what time of day. Hospitals need to have a pharmacist
available on a 24-hour basis. More dialogue between nurses and
pharmacists can only improves patient outcomes and decreases the
chances of medication errors occurring.
As pharmacology and technology advances, patients
should be able to expect a nurse who is continually updated on
new medications and the ways they are delivered. Good nursing
practice dictates that nurses are never to administer a drug they
are unfamiliar with. If a patient is to receive a drug that is
too new to be in the usual reference books, nurses should insist
that information be provided to them. And they should not administer
that drug until they have enough information to be comfortable
doing so.
- THE RIGHT TO HAVE POLICIES ON MEDICATION
ADMINISTRATION
It is the responsibility of health care administration
to provide the structure necessary for nurses to administer medications
safely. Nursing practice is governed by the Board of Regulation
in Nursing but nursing policies are what guide nursing practice
at that health care entity. Policies often protect the nurse from
litigation should an error occur. Conversely, not following policy
or administrating medication without a policy will put the nurse
at risk not only for litigation but can result in license suspension
or forfeit.
New medications enter the market daily. Research
discovers new uses and ways to administer old medications. Administrators
are not practitioners; they need to be updated by staff on new
trends in medication administration. Subsequently, nursing administrators
need to initiate and develop systems that promote safe medication
administration. Nursing administrators have to insist that nurses
of their organization be allowed to deliver patient care in the
safest environment possible.
- THE RIGHT TO ADMINSTER MEDICATIONS SAFELY
AND TO IDENTIFY PROBLEMS IN THE SYSTEM
Nurses are the experts on what impacts safe medication
administration. Shaping systems and creating solution for safe
medication administration should include those who actually do
the work of administering medications.
Nurses have the right to speak up when they see
situations that can potentially result in medication errors. System
glitches that place the patient at risk need to be addressed and
corrected. Repeated breaks in the system can only be fixed if
at first it is identified. Just as you would advocate for a patient,
you should advocate for your ability to practice in a safe setting.
Your input is of tremendous value to all.
- THE RIGHT TO STOP, THINK, AND BE VIGILANT
WHEN ADMINISTERING MEDICATIONS
Nurses know medication administration is serious
business. Often nurses are caught up in the hustle and hassle
of a busy work place. With decreases in licensed staff and organizational
support and increasing patient acuity, nurses still manage to
do it all. But we are human, we are all fallible. There is only
so much sensory input a person can handle, only so many questions
one can process at a time.
When we find our minds so overloaded we are unable
to think. We have the right to stop and do so. When we see orders
that somehow do not make sense even if we can not identify why
this order seems odd, we have the right to stop and find out why.
When we are about to administer a drug we are unfamiliar with,
we have the right to stop and find out about this new drug. If
we need to ask other nurses or professionals about this drug or
check the policy for giving this drug, we need to stop and do
so. Will this take additional time? Yes. Will others think we
are stupid? Maybe. Will some people become irritated with us?
Probably.
But, if stopping to think before administering
medications to your patient seems like an inconvenience, ask yourself
this question: Would I rather be known as the nurse who is slow
giving her meds, or the nurse who did her patient harm?
Unsafe medication administration situations will
be lessened as long as nurses continue to recognize problems and
steadfastly protect their patients and their practice. Nurses
need to take the time to identify and address sloppiness in their
work place and in other professionals. Confrontation is not easy
for nurses. Nurses would rather fix it themselves. This system
only perpetuates others’ poor practice and allows the nurse
to assume responsibility for all. This is not our job. Our allegiance
is to our patients.