Mass Nurses Association
News Events Legislation Safe Ratios Single Payer Labor Relations Get a Union Join Participate
Nursing Practice Health and Safety Continuing Education Career Services Peer Assistance Program Member Benefits Links
About Us Contact Us Site Map
The Latest Developments in the Massachusetts Nursing Environment  
   
SEARCH
      
Top Stories
News Archive
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
   
 
  Brockton Nurses Applaud the Legislators' Letter , Specifically Its Call for the Hospital to Satisfactorily Address the Nurses' Concerns Over Staffing and Mandatory Overtime. This Letter Follows Similar Appeal from Senate President Thomas Birmingham & Entire Mass. Congressional Delegation

137 Legislators Cosign Letter to Brockton Hospital CEO/Trustees Supporting Nurses and Urging Management to Negotiate a Fair Settlement to End Nurses' Strike (Now 69 Days)

BROCKTON, Mass. —This week, 137 Massachusetts legislators cosigned a letter delivered to Brockton CEO Norman Goodman calling upon the hospital to "take the initiative and responsibility" to reach a fair settlement to end the nurses' strike that is now 69 days old. A copy of the letter and list of the cosigners can be found at the end of this press release.

"We believe the that the long term health of Brockton Hospital is at the core of the nurses' concerns," the letter to Goodman reads. "More specifically, we are concerned that low staffing and mandatory overtime puts an undue burden on the nurses, and we believe that the practice has the very real potential to decrease the quality of care for which Brockton Hospital and its staff are justly recognized."

The letter states the legislators' belief that the "nurses are acting in good faith" and states their hope that the hospital is truly "committed to ending this strike amicably."

"The nurses are extremely gratified that so many of the state's elected officials have spoken out on our behalf," said Linda McMahon, co-chair of the nurses' bargaining unit and a nurse for 17 years at Brockton Hospital. "They clearly understand the impact of unsafe staffing and mandatory overtime has on patients and families served by this hospital and have acknowledged that a settlement to this strike must address these pivotal issues."

The letter was drafted by State Rep. Christine Canavan of Brockton, a registered nurse and staunch supporter of the striking nurses. The letter is cosigned by the entire Brockton legislative delegation, with signatures from 30 of the states' 40 senators and 107 of the state's 157 representatives.

The legislative appeal follows two similar letters sent to the hospital management and trustees last week; including one from Senate President Thomas Birmingham and another letter cosigned by the entire Massachusetts congressional delegation. This is in addition to an appeal made three weeks ago by Massachusetts Senators Edward M. Kennedy and John F. Kerry.

As political support for the nurses grows and calls for the hospital to negotiate in good faith to end the strike intensifies, Brockton management has continued to refuse to make any substantive effort to bring the costly strike to a close. Talks last week, which was only the third time the parties had met since the strike began on May 25, ended when management refused to offer any formal proposals for the nurses to consider. Specifically, the hospital refuses to budge on the central issue in dispute, which is the nurses' call for a contractual commitment by the hospital to use its best efforts to fully staff the hospital to avoid the practice of mandatory overtime.

The nurses have been waiting since May 22 for the hospital to make a comprehensive proposal to move the talks towards a settlement to end the strike.

The contract language the nurses have been seeking to address staffing and mandatory overtime concerns is the same language that was negotiated by the nurses at St. Vincent Hospital last year, which ended the nurses 49-day strike. This same language, or language like it has been accepted by three other Massachusetts hospitals in the last four months. It is the first paragraph of this proposal that is the primary cause of the strike. Specifically, it reads: "The Hospital will reasonably determine the level of registered nurse staffing needed for safe and appropriate care on all nursing units, and will exercise its best efforts to provide that level of staffing through its regular and per diem nursing force without resort to overtime." By including this "staffing" language into the nurses' contract, the issue becomes subject to the traditional grievance and arbitration process. The hospital opposes the accountability such a provision mandates. The nurses believe they can no longer provide safe care to their patients, nor safely fulfill their obligations as a licensed nurse without some guarantee that the hospital will be held accountable for its staffing decisions.

Nurses at Brockton Hospital have a long history of problems with management over the issue of mandatory overtime, i.e. forcing a nurse against her/his will to work extra hours or shifts to compensate for a lack of appropriate staffing. It was the principle issue of concern in their last contract negotiations of 1998. While the hospital had promised to eliminate the problem, the practice continued at an even higher rate. The underlying cause of mandatory overtime is a shortage of staff. The hospital has refused to recruit and retain enough staff to safely operate the facility, while it has dramatically increased its census (patient volume) in recent years. There simply aren't enough nurses hired by the hospital to cover the shifts required to care for the patients being admitted to the facility.






Text of Letter:

THE GENERAL COURT OF MASSACHUSETTS
STATE HOUSE, BOSTON 02133-1053


July 30, 2001

Mr. Norman B. Goodman
President and Chief Executive Officer
Brockton Hospital
680 Centre St.
Brockton, MA 02302
  Board of Trustees
Brockton Hospital
680 Centre St.
Brockton, MA 02302

Dear Mr. Goodman and the Board of Trustees:

We are writing to urge you to take responsibility and initiative necessary to settle the labor dispute between Brockton Hospital management and the registered nurses employed at the hospital. We join other elected officials and leaders of your community in urging a renewed focus and commitment to a compromise to end this strike.

We are seeking a quick, fair resolution of this dispute because we are concerned about the lasting impact of this strike on Brockton and surrounding communities.

Brockton Hospital provides a vital service to the Southeastern region, and we know of the quality and dedication of the nurses that staff the facility. We believe that the long-term health of Brockton Hospital is at the core of the nurses' concerns. A majority of the nurses reside in the very communities that depend on the services provided by the hospital, and many of the nurses have worked there for the majority of their professional careers. More specifically, we are concerned that low staffing and mandatory overtime puts an undue burden on the nurses, and we believe that the practice has the very real potential to decrease the quality of care for which Brockton Hospital and its staff is justly recognized. We believe that nurses are acting in good faith and remain hopeful that the substantial common ground shared by both parties does not become overshadowed by the points of difference.

We hope you are committed to ending this strike amicably. A compromise and quick resolution to this strike are beneficial to all parties and we encourage you to complete these negotiations.

We look forward to your response.

Sincerely,

STATE SENATORS
Stephen Brewer -Barre - D
Harriette Chandler - Worcester - D
Edward Clancy - Lynn - D
Robert Creedon - Brockton - D
Cynthia Creem - Newton - D
Susan Fargo - Lincoln - D
Guy William Glodis - Worcester - D
Robert Hedlund - Weymouth - R
Cheryl Jacques - Needham - D
James Jajuga - Methuen - D
Brian Joyce - Milton - D
Stephen F. Lynch - Boston - D
David Magnani - Framingham - D
Joan Menard - Somerset - D
Mark Montigny - New Bedford - D
Richard Moore - Uxbridge - D
Michael Morrissey - Quincy - D
Terry Murray - Plymouth - D
Robert O'Leary - Barnstable - D
Marc Pacheco - Taunton - D
Pamela Resor Acton - D
Stanley Rosenberg Amherst - D
Charles Shannon Winchester - D
Jo Ann Sprague Walpole - R
Bruce Tarr Gloucester - R
Richard Tisei Wakefield - R
Steven Tolman Brighton - D
Susan Tucker Andover - D
Marian Walsh Boston - D
Dianne Wilkerson Boston - D

STATE REPRESENTATIVES
Cory Atkins Concord - D
Demetrius Atsalis Barnstable - D
Bruce Ayers Randolph - D
Ruth Balser Newton -D
Jarrett Barrios Cambridge - D
John Binienda, Sr. Worcester - D
Deborah D. Blumer Framingham - D
Daniel Bosley North Adams - D
David Bunker Rutland - D
Stephen Buoniconti West Springfield - D
Michael Cahill Beverly - D
Christine Canavan Brockton - D
Gale Candaras Wilbraham - D
Paul Caron Springfield - D
Mark Carron Southbridge -D
Vincent Ciampa omerville - D
Edward Connolly Everett - D
Geraldine Creedon Brockton -D
Paul Demakis Back Bay - D
Paul Donato Medford - D
Carol Donovan Woburn - D
James Fagan Taunton - D
Christopher Fallon Malden - D
Mark V. Falzone Saugus - D
Robert Fennell Lynn - D
Michael Festa Melrose - D
Kevin Fitzgerald Mission Hill - D
David Flynn Bridgewater - D
Gloria Fox Boston - D
John Fresolo Worcester - D
William Galvin Canton - D
Colleen Garry Dracut - D
Emile Goguen Fitchburg - D
Brian Golden Brighton - D
Thomas Golden Lowell - D
Shirley Gomes Harwich - R
William Greene Billerica - D
Patricia A. Haddad Somerset - D
Geoffrey Hall Westford - D
Robert Hargraves Groton - R
Lida Harkins Needham - D
John Hart South Boston - D
Kevin Honan Brighton - D
Frank Hynes Marshfield - D
Patricia Jehlen Somerville - D
Louis Kafka Sharon - D
Michael Kane Holyoke - D
Rachel Kaprielian Watertown - D
Jay Kaufman Lexington - D
Daniel Keenan Blandford - D
Thomas Kennedy Brockton - D
Kay Khan Newton - D
Brian Knuutilla Gardner - D
Robert Koczera New Bedford - D
Peter Koutoujian Newton - D
Paul Kujawski Webster - D
James B. Leary Worcester - D
Stephen LeDuc Marlboro - D
Maryanne Lewis Dedham - D
David Linsky Natick - D
Liz Malia Jamaica Plain - D
Ronald Mariano Quincy - D
Jim Marzilli Arlington - D
Thomas McGee Lynn - D
James Miceli Wilmington - D
Charles Murphy Burlington - D
James Murphy Wilmington - D
Kevin Murphy Lowell - D
David Nangle Lowell - D
Harold Naughton Clinton - D
Robert Nyman Hanover - D
Thomas O'Brien Kingston - D
Eugene O'Flaherty Chelsea - D
Shirley Owens-Hicks Roxbury - D
Marie Parente Milford - D
Matthew Patrick Falmouth - D
Anne Paulsen Belmont - D
Vincent Pedone Worcester - D
Doug Petersen Marblehead - D
Anthony Petruccelli Boston - D
Ruth Provost Sandwich - D
John Quinn Dartmouth - D
Kathi-Anne Reinstein Revere - D
Michael Rodrigues Fall River - D
George Rogers New Bedford - D
Michael Ruane Salem - D
Byron Rushing Boston - D
Mary Jane Simmons Leominster - D
John Slattery Peabody - D
Frank I. Smizik Brookline D
Theodore Speliotis Danvers - D
Robert Spellane Worcester - D
Ellen Story Amherst - D
William Straus Mattapoisett - D
David Sullivan Fall River - D
Joseph Sullivan Braintree - D
Benjamin Swan Springfield - D
Kathleen Teahan Whitman - D
Walter Timility Milton - D
Paul Tirone Amesbury - D
Stephen Tobin Quincy - D
Timothy Toomey, Jr. Cambridge - D
Philip Travis Rehoboth - D
Eric Turkington Falmouth - D
James Vallee Franklin - D
Martin Walsh Dorchester - D
Alice Wolf Cambridge - D



Back to Brockton Strike Page

 
         
 

[news] [activists alerts] [legislation] [safe care] [universal health care] [labor relations] [organizing] [how to join] [member opps]
[nursing practice] [health issues] [MNA courses] [job opps] [substance abuse counseling] [member benefits] [nursing links]
[about us] [contact us] [site map]
[home]